Netflix One Piece Live Action vs Anime: Which is Better and What’s the Difference?

Netflix’s live-action adaptation of “One Piece” has been hailed by many as one of the best anime adaptations to date. With its breathtaking fight scenes and impeccable character designs, it’s no surprise that fans are raving. However, as with any adaptation, there are bound to be changes. Let’s dive into the most significant alterations the live-action series made from the beloved anime.

Garp’s Enhanced Role

In the original anime, Vice-Admiral Garp’s involvement is limited in the early chapters. He’s notably absent during the execution of Gol D. Roger and doesn’t make an appearance until after the East Blue Saga concludes. However, Netflix’s version amplifies Garp’s role, showcasing him right from the beginning. His training of Kobe and Helmpoppo, which was mostly off-screen in the anime, is brought to the forefront. This increased focus on Garp adds depth to the series, though some purists might argue it deviates too much from the original.

Netflix’s ‘One Piece’ Revamp: Hits & Misses

Character Introductions: A New Spin

While every character’s introduction has been tweaked, Zoro’s stands out the most. Instead of being discovered at a Marine base, Zoro’s first appearance is on Sixis island, clashing with an agent from Baroque Works. This change is significant since Baroque Works doesn’t feature in the anime until the Arabasta Saga, well after the East Blue Saga.

Buggy’s Arc: A Complete Overhaul

The Orange Town arc, which revolves around Buggy, underwent a massive transformation. The entire episode takes place in a big top circus rather than Orange Town. This shift means many characters, like Chouchou, the brave little dog, are left out. These omissions might leave some fans longing for the original’s depth and character development.

Live-Action ‘One Piece’: Netflix’s Fresh Spin

The Syrup Village Arc’s Revamp

The Syrup Village arc, which introduces the sharpshooter Usoop, saw several changes. The bustling port town setting, the omission of the Usoop Pirates, and the absence of Jango the Hypnotist are just a few of the alterations. While the live-action episodes were thrilling, the lack of comic relief characters was palpable.

Don Krieg’s Diminished Role

Don Krieg, the primary antagonist of the Baratie arc in the anime, is reduced to a mere cameo in the live-action series. Steven Maeda, the showrunner, explained that this was to establish Arlong as the main villain of Season 1. This shift in focus might be jarring for fans of the anime.

One Piece Live Action is a masterpiece ✨

— One Piece Tweets (@onepiecedaiIys) September 9, 2023

Nami’s Village: A Shift in Dynamics

The dynamics in Nami’s village, Cocyasi, underwent a significant change. In the anime, the villagers secretly support Nami, but in the live-action series, they are oblivious to her sacrifices. This change impacts Nami’s character development and her relationship with the villagers.

Arlong’s Enhanced Presence

Arlong’s character is more fleshed out in the live-action series, making him a more complex villain. His early introduction and the omission of some of his crew members, like Momoo, are notable changes that reshape the narrative.

Garp and Luffy’s Relationship Revealed

One of the boldest changes is the early revelation of Garp and Luffy’s familial ties. This decision, while controversial, adds depth to their relationship and sets the stage for future conflicts.

One Piece’ on Netflix: New Twists Revealed

The Missing Loguetown Arc

The omission of the Loguetown Arc, which concludes the East Blue Saga in the anime, is a significant deviation. While it’s hinted at towards the end of Season 1, its absence is felt by fans who were expecting a comprehensive adaptation of the East Blue Saga.


Adapting a beloved series like “One Piece” is no easy task. While Netflix’s live-action series has made several changes, both minor and major, it offers a fresh perspective on a classic tale. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of the anime or new to the world of “One Piece,” this adaptation is worth a watch.